Legal & Disputes
W Real Estate Defends Dual Agency as City 44 Lawsuits Head to 2027 Trials
By News Desk ·
Key takeaways
- At least 24 plaintiffs are part of DiBari vs. Morgan Properties, which alleges subpar stucco construction at City 44 in Santa Rosa.
- Ochoa vs. W Real Estate challenges dual agency deals in which the brokerage represented both buyer and seller.
- The dual agency trial is scheduled for May 2027, the DTI case for August 2027 and DiBari for September 2027.
At least 24 plaintiffs are suing Morgan Properties over construction defects at the City 44 development in Santa Rosa, while a separate class action targets W Real Estate over dual agency deals in the same project. Both cases are headed to trial in Sonoma County Superior Court in 2027, the Press Democrat reported.
Inside the City 44 Lawsuits
The DiBari case, filed in July 2024, alleges breach of contract, false promise, breach of fiduciary duty and constructive fraud. It began with 18 plaintiffs and grew to at least 24 through six amended complaints; all bought single-family homes in City 44 between April 2022 and early 2023. The developer was Enclave Santa Rosa LP, a Marin County entity controlled by Morgan Properties. The complaint alleges the homes were sided with "a cheap knock-off single-coat stucco system" instead of the specified Ultrakote WM EIFS product, leading to cracks, water intrusion, mold and dry rot. Daniel Morgan, the developer, said his company knew of no defects when the houses were sold. "Had we known, we would have corrected the defects — to the extent they exist, I might add," he said. Morgan filed a cross-complaint in September 2025 against 10 subcontractors. In April, Judge Oscar Pardo ordered Morgan to pay more than $20,000 in sanctions for failing to produce evidentiary documents on time; the plaintiffs had sought $37,000.
The class action, Ochoa vs. W Real Estate, centers on a listing agreement between Enclave and the brokerage that required W to "represent both buyer and seller in all transactions." Randy Waller, co-owner of W Real Estate, defended the practice. "This is the industry standard," he said. The lawsuit alleges W handled exclusive dual agency listings in at least 730 sales.
W Real Estate's North Bay Footprint
W Real Estate is a privately held, commission-based brokerage headquartered in Santa Rosa, according to akta.pro company records. The brokerage was founded in 2007 and describes itself as the largest privately owned and operated real estate company north of the Golden Gate Bridge. It has launched W Commercial, a commercial brokerage sub-brand, and W Marketing New Homes, which serves new construction developers and buyers in Calistoga, Windsor and other North Bay markets.
Other Property Disputes in Court
A São Paulo court ruled that Vitacon must pay a 1% monthly fine on paid amounts and reimburse condominium fees for apartments delivered with unfinished infrastructure, Estadao reported on November 21. Brookfield Asset Management faces allegations it breached an agreement to pursue a joint venture, a case tied to its 2025 acquisition of three Singapore properties and a S$535.3 million Mapletree deal, The Business Times reported on November 20. In New Hampshire, developer Brady Sullivan is challenging Hooksett's $800,000 impact fee assessment and offering a $225,000 donation instead, with a public hearing set for December 9, Yahoo reported on November 19.
Trial Dates Set for 2027
The dual agency lawsuit is scheduled for trial in May 2027. The DTI case, filed in October 2025 by Santa Rosa property management company DTI LLC over two Alnico Lane homes, is set for August 2027, and DiBari for September 2027.