Legal & Disputes
Upper Peninsula Environmental Coalition and Allies Sue Forest Service Over Silver Branch Logging Project
By News Desk ·
Key takeaways
- The Upper Peninsula Environmental Coalition, the Environmental Law and Policy Center and the Natural Resources Defense Council filed a federal lawsuit against the U.S. Forest Service over the Silver Branch Vegetation Management Project.
- The groups say more than 25,000 acres would be clearcut and another 55,000 acres would see selection harvests, thinning and other logging.
- The lawsuit asks the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan to vacate the Forest Service's environmental assessment and decision.
The Upper Peninsula Environmental Coalition, the Environmental Law and Policy Center and the Natural Resources Defense Council sued the U.S. Forest Service in federal court on Tuesday, seeking to vacate the agency's approval of the Silver Branch Vegetation Management Project and its environmental assessment. Yahoo reported the filing, which argues the approval violates the National Environmental Policy Act.
The Upper Peninsula Environmental Coalition is a Michigan advocacy group that works on environmental issues in the Upper Peninsula and maintains a website at upenvironment.org. The U.S. Forest Service approved the project in July for the east side of the Ottawa National Forest.
Inside the Silver Branch Lawsuit
The Forest Service described the 30-year effort as intended to protect clean water, support wildlife habitats and strengthen recreation opportunities. The groups argue the agency did not fully evaluate the environmental impacts of a planned timber harvest across nearly 80,000 acres of the project area.
According to the lawsuit, more than 25,000 acres would be subject to clearcuts, while another 55,000 acres would see selection harvests, thinning and other forms of logging. The groups say those activities could harm species including the endangered northern long-eared bat, and that endangered wolves and other wildlife could be displaced by noise and human presence for up to 10 years.
"A thorough environmental review is part of a proven process that helps ensure that logging on federal lands is done responsibly," Kelly Thayer, senior policy advocate for the Environmental Law and Policy Center, said in a statement Wednesday. "This attempt to bypass the law is part of a series of failed attempts by the Trump administration to streamline operations without considering the consequences."
The lawsuit also contends the Forest Service defied the terms of the Ottawa's own management plan by authorizing logging on lands the forest designated as unsuitable for timber harvest. It further states that approving extensive clearcuts will worsen the forest's problems with deer browsing and tree regeneration, in violation of both the Ottawa's plan and the National Forest Management Act.
The Forest Service determined the project would have no significant impact on the environment. The agency was asked to comment and did not respond in time for publication.
What the Groups Want From the Court
The groups have asked the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan to vacate the Forest Service's environmental assessment and its decision approving the Silver Branch project. The case was filed Tuesday in federal court.
Companies in this story
- Upper Peninsula Environmental Coalition · www.upenvironment.org
- The Center for Environmental Law and Policy company profile · www.celp.org
- U.S. Forest Service company profile · www.fs.usda.gov