Regulation & Approvals
Wisconsin DNR Alleges 34 Violations on Enbridge's $1 Billion Line 5 Reroute
By News Desk ·
Key takeaways
- The Wisconsin DNR issued a notice of violation alleging 34 violations on Enbridge's Line 5 reroute, including four drilling fluid releases that reached wetlands or waterways.
- An August 25 line strike near Saxon released 1.3 million gallons of natural gas liquids, the largest such spill in Wisconsin history.
- DNR Secretary Karen Hyun asked Enbridge to halt work, but the agency would need a court injunction to require it.
- Enbridge spokesperson Juli Kellner said the vast majority of concerns were resolved with the agency within one day of being identified.
Wisconsin's Department of Natural Resources has accused Enbridge of 34 violations on its roughly $1 billion Line 5 reroute, including a 1.3 million gallon natural gas liquids spill on August 25 near Saxon in Iron County. The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, in a report published by Yahoo, said the DNR issued a notice of violation citing "a persistent pattern of non-compliance."
Inside the DNR's Line 5 Violation Notice
The DNR approved the permits in November 2024 for the 41-mile reroute around the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa's land. The notice cites four drilling fluid releases, or frac-outs, from March through September, all of which reached wetlands or waterways. The Journal Sentinel learned of 12 reported releases across at least eight of the project's 13 drill sites; the DNR confirmed 10 involved drilling fluid, and Earthjustice, the nonprofit law firm representing the Bad River Band, said the other two were related to the reroute.
DNR Secretary Karen Hyun has asked Enbridge to halt work, but the agency has no power to require it without a court injunction or a permit modification or revocation. Enbridge spokesperson Juli Kellner said in a November 5 statement that "the vast majority of concerns noted ... were resolved in coordination with the agency within one day of being identified" and that "all are already mitigated or are in the process of being addressed." Bad River Band Chairwoman Elizabeth Arbuckle said: "I hope Wisconsin hasn't abandoned us."
Enbridge's Scale Against State Penalties
According to akta.pro company records, Enbridge reported GAAP earnings of $7.1 billion ($3.23 per share) for 2025 and adjusted EBITDA of $20.0 billion, a 7% increase over 2024. The Calgary-based company, founded in 1949, holds a secured growth backlog of approximately $39 billion across natural gas, liquids and renewables. The Journal Sentinel noted that the maximum daily penalty for a discharge and stormwater violation is $10,000.
Earlier Enbridge Spill and Pipeline Events
In November 2024, Enbridge discovered that its Line 6 had leaked about 69,000 gallons of crude oil at a pump station in Jefferson County, according to the Journal Sentinel. Seven years after a 2019 spill from its Line 13 pipeline in the same county, Enbridge agreed to pay $275,000 over allegations it failed to report the spill for more than a year, with the settlement announced June 25. Two days later, the reroute's first reported frac-out spilled up to 1,900 gallons of drilling fluid.
What Comes Next for the Line 5 Permits
More than 30 environmental, tribal and faith groups have called on Gov. Tony Evers to revoke the permits. The DNR met with Enbridge on October 26 for an enforcement conference, and on October 28 the agency approved a statewide general permit allowing two temporary bridges to stay in place while the company removes the bypass and cleans up the site.